What I Learned From Talking to 60 People About Retiring Early

40

The Unexpected Truth About Leaving the 9-to-5 Behind

You’ve probably daydreamed about it during a particularly grueling Monday morning meeting. The idea of retiring early—walking away from corporate life while you still have energy, health, and decades ahead of you. But here’s what keeps most people frozen: the fear of running out of money, the uncertainty of healthcare costs, and the nagging question of whether you’ve truly saved enough.

Over the past eighteen months, I’ve had deep, candid conversations with 60 individuals who successfully retired early—some in their late 40s, others at 55 or 58. What I learned from talking to 60 people about retiring early completely reshaped my understanding of what early retirement actually requires, both financially and emotionally. These weren’t trust fund beneficiaries or lottery winners. They were teachers, engineers, small business owners, and corporate managers who made deliberate choices over 15 to 25 years.

This article shares the patterns I discovered, the mistakes they avoided, and the surprising truths they wish they’d known sooner. Whether you’re just beginning to explore early retirement or you’re already fine-tuning your exit strategy, these insights will help you navigate the journey with greater confidence and clarity.

Key Points

• Early retirement requires addressing emotional identity shifts beyond just financial preparation
• Healthcare coverage before Medicare eligibility demands strategic planning and significant budgeting
• Tax optimization strategies can preserve wealth better than aggressive investment returns alone
• Geographic flexibility and spending patterns matter more than absolute net worth figures
• Purpose-driven activities prevent the psychological pitfalls many early retirees experience

What Early Retirement Actually Means (And Why Age 60 Matters)

Defining “Early” in Today’s Retirement Landscape

Is 60 considered early retirement? According to the Social Security Administration, full retirement age ranges from 66 to 67 for most workers today, making 60 technically early by about six to seven years. But among the people I interviewed, “early retirement” meant something more personal—it was leaving the workforce before they felt societal pressure to do so, often between ages 45 and 58.

The Social Security Administration’s benefit reduction schedule shows that claiming at 60 isn’t even an option for most people (unless you’re a surviving spouse with specific circumstances). You can start drawing reduced benefits at 62, but the financial penalty is substantial—about 30% less than waiting until full retirement age. This creates what I call the “gap years challenge”—funding life between your last paycheck and when you can access retirement accounts or Social Security without severe penalties.

The Real Numbers Behind Early Retirement

Among the 60 early retirees I spoke with, the average retirement age was 54. Here’s what surprised me: their median net worth at retirement was $1.8 million, but the range was enormous—from $850,000 to over $4 million. What mattered more than the absolute number was their annual spending relative to their assets.

Most followed variations of the 4% rule, but nearly all had adjusted it downward to 3% to 3.5% to account for longer retirement horizons. When you retire at 54 instead of 67, you’re potentially funding 35-40 years instead of 20-25 years. That’s not just more years—it’s more years exposed to sequence-of-returns risk, inflation erosion, and unexpected health events. Understanding these retirement investment strategies became critical for their long-term success.

Beyond the Financial Metrics

One conversation stands out. Maria, a former marketing director who retired at 52, told me: “I had the money figured out down to the penny. What I didn’t have figured out was who I’d be without my business cards.” This identity shift caught 47 of the 60 people off-guard. Your career doesn’t just provide income—it provides structure, social connection, status, and purpose.

The most successful early retirees had spent time before retirement exploring what I call “purpose anchors”—volunteer work, passion projects, community involvement, or part-time consulting. They didn’t just retire from something; they retired to something specific. This psychological preparation proved as valuable as their financial planning, addressing what many struggle with in retirement savings psychology.

The Five Financial Lessons That Surprised Me Most

Healthcare Costs Are Larger and More Complex Than Expected

This was unanimous: healthcare coverage before Medicare eligibility at 65 represents one of the biggest—and most underestimated—expenses in early retirement. For someone retiring at 55, that’s a decade of private health insurance. In 2024, average marketplace premiums for a couple in their late 50s can range from $1,500 to $2,500 monthly, depending on location and coverage level.

But here’s the sophisticated strategy I learned: many early retirees deliberately managed their income to qualify for Affordable Care Act subsidies. By living off Roth conversions, strategic capital gains harvesting, and taxable account withdrawals, they kept their Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) within subsidy-eligible ranges. One couple showed me how they reduced their annual healthcare costs from $28,000 to $8,400 through careful income planning.

They also built separate healthcare sinking funds—dedicated savings specifically for medical expenses during the Medicare gap years. These weren’t their emergency funds; they were targeted reserves for a known, substantial future expense. Creating this dedicated fund was as important as establishing a general emergency fund for retirement.

Geographic Arbitrage Changes Everything

Thirty-two of the 60 people I interviewed either moved to lower cost-of-living areas or split their time between locations strategically. This wasn’t about deprivation—it was about optimization. A couple from San Francisco moved to Asheville, North Carolina, and discovered their $3,200 monthly housing cost dropped to $1,800 for comparable quality of life. That $1,400 monthly difference equals $16,800 annually, or $420,000 over a 25-year retirement at a 4% withdrawal rate.

Some embraced even more creative approaches. Four couples became “geographic nomads,” spending summers in affordable college towns in the U.S. and winters in countries like Portugal, Mexico, or Costa Rica where their dollars stretched further. They weren’t running from anything—they were running toward adventure while making their retirement savings last longer.

The key insight? Location flexibility is a powerful financial lever that traditional retirement planning often ignores. When you’re no longer tied to an employer’s location, you gain options that can dramatically reduce your required nest egg.

Tax Strategy Matters More Than Investment Returns

This shocked me. I expected conversations about stock picking and market timing. Instead, I heard detailed discussions about Roth conversion ladders, tax-loss harvesting, and qualified dividend strategies. The early retirees who felt most financially secure weren’t necessarily the ones with the highest returns—they were the ones who paid the least in taxes.

Consider this example: James retired at 56 with $1.4 million split between traditional IRAs, Roth IRAs, and taxable brokerage accounts. For his first five years of retirement, he lived primarily off his taxable accounts while systematically converting portions of his traditional IRA to Roth. By staying in the 12% and 22% tax brackets during these conversions, he avoided future Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) that would have pushed him into higher brackets later.

The IRS rules on early distributions became their second language. They mastered exceptions like Substantially Equal Periodic Payments (SEPP/72(t)), understood the Roth conversion five-year rule, and planned around the pro-rata rule for backdoor Roth contributions. Navigating these retirement tax considerations saved them tens of thousands of dollars annually.

Flexibility Beats Precision in Financial Planning

Traditional retirement planning tries to predict the unpredictable: investment returns, inflation rates, lifespan, and spending needs decades in advance. The successful early retirees I spoke with took a different approach—they built flexibility into their plans rather than trying to perfect their projections.

What does flexibility look like? It’s maintaining skills that allow part-time consulting income if markets crash early in retirement. It’s keeping housing costs low enough that downsizing remains an option. It’s structuring spending into “essential” and “discretionary” buckets, knowing the discretionary portion can be cut during bear markets.

Twelve people mentioned using what they called “variable spending strategies”—spending more when markets performed well and tightening belts during downturns. This dynamic approach reduced their risk of portfolio depletion far more effectively than rigid withdrawal rules. They avoided the common retirement planning mistakes that assume life and markets follow predictable patterns.

The Safety Net Is Multiple Layers, Not One Big Number

When I asked, “How did you know you had enough?” I expected to hear about specific net worth targets. Instead, I heard about layered safety nets. They didn’t rely on just their investment portfolio—they built multiple sources of security.

These layers included: paid-off primary residences (38 of 60 were mortgage-free), multiple income streams (rental properties, royalties, part-time work), delayed Social Security for maximum benefits, Health Savings Accounts used as stealth retirement accounts, and long-term care insurance or dedicated funds for potential care needs. This comprehensive approach aligned with effective retirement budget planning principles.

The fear of outliving retirement savings diminished significantly when they had five or six backup plans rather than depending entirely on their portfolio performance. This redundancy created psychological peace that a single large nest egg never could.

The Emotional and Psychological Realities Nobody Warns You About

The First Year Is Harder Than Expected

Twenty-three people described their first year of early retirement as disorienting, even those who’d planned meticulously. After decades of structure—alarm clocks, meetings, deadlines, and clear performance metrics—the sudden absence of external structure felt uncomfortable.

Sarah, a former attorney who retired at 53, put it this way: “I spent six months just decompressing. I’d wake up at 7 a.m. with anxiety, feeling like I was supposed to be somewhere. It took nearly a year to stop defining myself by what I used to do and start embracing what I was becoming.”

The solution? A gradual transition worked better than a hard stop. Several people negotiated part-time consulting arrangements with their former employers for the first year or two. Others front-loaded their retirement with structured activities—language classes, volunteer commitments, or planned travel—to ease into unstructured time.

Social Connections Require Intentional Rebuilding

Here’s an uncomfortable truth: many of your friendships are work friendships. When you leave the workplace, especially before your peers do, those connections often fade. Nineteen people mentioned feeling socially isolated in their first two years of retirement, despite having anticipated this intellectually.

The successful navigators of this challenge treated social connection building as seriously as they’d treated wealth building. They joined clubs, took classes, volunteered regularly, and intentionally cultivated friendships with other retired or semi-retired people who shared their daytime availability.

One man told me he applied the same discipline to social life that he’d applied to saving. He set a goal of three social activities weekly and tracked it. It sounds mechanical, but it worked—within eighteen months, he had a thriving social calendar and deep friendships that had nothing to do with his former career.

Purpose Matters More Than Leisure

Permanent vacation sounds wonderful until you’re living it. After the initial excitement of unstructured time wore off (typically three to six months), many early retirees craved meaningful work, just not the soul-crushing kind they’d left behind.

The happiest early retirees had clear answers to “What will you do with your time?” before they retired. Some mentored young professionals in their former fields. Others pursued creative passions—writing, woodworking, painting—that their careers had crowded out. Several started small businesses, not for income necessity but for engagement and contribution.

What is the point of retiring early? Based on these conversations, it’s not about stopping work—it’s about choosing your work. It’s about reclaiming your time to invest it in things that matter to you personally rather than things that matter to your employer or clients. The most fulfilled early retirees viewed retirement as a career change to self-directed projects rather than an ending.

The Practical Frameworks That Actually Work

Understanding the 60/30/10 Rule for Retirement

What is the 60/30/10 rule for retirement? Several people mentioned variations of spending allocation frameworks, though interpretations varied. The most common version I encountered allocated 60% of retirement income to essential expenses (housing, healthcare, food, utilities), 30% to discretionary lifestyle spending (travel, hobbies, entertainment), and 10% to unexpected expenses and giving.

This framework provides flexibility while ensuring essentials are covered even during market downturns. When investments underperform, discretionary spending in the 30% bucket can be reduced without threatening core security. The 10% buffer for unexpected expenses prevents lifestyle disruption when the car needs replacement or the roof requires repair.

Others flipped this framework for their investment allocation: 60% in growth-oriented investments, 30% in income-generating assets, and 10% in cash or cash equivalents. This provided growth potential while ensuring adequate liquidity for near-term needs. The key was having a structured approach rather than making ad-hoc decisions during stressful market conditions.

Building Your Retirement Income Plan

The most sophisticated early retirees didn’t just have savings—they had engineered income streams. Their retirement income plans resembled carefully constructed ecosystems with multiple components working together.

A typical structure included: taxable account withdrawals for the first few years (while in lower tax brackets), Roth conversions during low-income years to minimize future RMDs, strategic use of capital gains (staying within the 0% long-term capital gains bracket when possible), rental income from one or two properties, and delayed Social Security filing to maximize lifetime benefits.

They sequenced their withdrawals strategically. Rather than proportionally drawing from all accounts, they withdrew from specific accounts in specific order to minimize lifetime taxes. This “tax-efficient withdrawal sequencing” saved them hundreds of thousands of dollars over a 30-year retirement compared to random withdrawal patterns.

The Role of Professional Guidance

Forty-one of the 60 early retirees worked with financial advisors, but not in the way you might expect. They didn’t hand over control—they collaborated. They educated themselves thoroughly, then used advisors for specialized expertise in areas like tax planning, estate planning, and insurance optimization.

The value they found wasn’t in investment management (many handled that themselves through low-cost index funds). The value was in comprehensive planning—running Monte Carlo simulations, stress-testing their plans against various scenarios, and optimizing the complex interactions between taxes, Social Security timing, and healthcare coverage. Finding the right financial advisor for retirement became a crucial step in their journey.

Several mentioned that their advisor’s greatest value came during market downturns, when emotional decision-making threatened to derail carefully laid plans. Having a professional provide perspective and prevent panic selling proved worth the advisory fees many times over.

What I Learned From Talking to 60 People About Retiring Early: The Common Threads

Starting Early Makes Everything Easier

This won’t surprise you, but it’s worth emphasizing: every person I spoke with had started saving seriously in their 20s or early 30s. They didn’t necessarily earn high incomes initially, but they developed high savings rates early—typically 20% to 40% of gross income from the start of their careers.

They automated their savings, lived below their means, and avoided lifestyle inflation as their incomes grew. What would have become a luxury car payment or a larger house became additional retirement contributions instead. This compounding over 20 to 25 years made early retirement possible without extreme deprivation.

Intentionality Beats Income Level

Here’s something that challenged my assumptions: high income wasn’t the defining factor. I spoke with early retirees who’d never earned more than $75,000 annually and others who’d made $250,000+. What distinguished successful early retirees wasn’t their income—it was their savings rate and intentional lifestyle design.

The modest earners succeeded by keeping expenses low, avoiding debt, and maximizing every tax-advantaged account available. The high earners succeeded by resisting lifestyle inflation and directing surplus income toward investments rather than luxury consumption. Both groups practiced what I call “conscious spending”—making deliberate choices about what truly added value to their lives versus what was just expensive noise.

Risk Management Is Personal

I expected consensus on the “right” asset allocation or withdrawal strategy. Instead, I found tremendous diversity based on personal risk tolerance. Some retired with 75% equity allocations, comfortable with volatility. Others shifted to 50/50 stocks-to-bonds, prioritizing stability over growth potential.

What united them wasn’t the specific numbers—it was that they’d thoughtfully considered their risk capacity (ability to absorb losses) and risk tolerance (emotional comfort with uncertainty). They’d stress-tested their plans, asking “What if the market crashes 40% in my second year of retirement?” and ensuring they could survive that scenario without returning to work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 60 considered early retirement?

Yes, 60 is generally considered early retirement since full Social Security retirement age is 66 to 67 for most current workers. Retiring at 60 means you’ll face several years before you can claim Social Security benefits without reduction (earliest is age 62 with penalties) and five years before Medicare eligibility at 65. This creates what financial planners call the “gap years” that require careful planning for healthcare coverage and income needs. The early retirees I interviewed who left at 60 had specifically addressed these gaps through private health insurance strategies and bridge income from taxable accounts or part-time work.

What is the point of retiring early?

The point of retiring early varies by individual, but common themes emerged from my conversations. Most people retire early to reclaim their time while they’re still healthy and energetic enough to fully enjoy it. They want freedom to pursue passions, travel, spend time with family, or contribute to causes that matter to them on their own terms rather than fitting life around work demands. Early retirement isn’t about endless leisure—it’s about choosing meaningful work and activities rather than having them dictated by economic necessity. The most satisfied early retirees retired “to” something specific (a passion project, volunteer work, creative pursuits) rather than just retiring “from” a job they disliked.

What is the best message for retirement?

The best retirement message balances realism with optimism. From my conversations, the most meaningful message is: “Retirement is not an end but a beginning—a transition to a new chapter where you define success on your own terms.” What resonated most with the people I interviewed was acknowledging that retirement brings both opportunities and challenges, and both deserve preparation. A good retirement message should honor the career being left behind while creating excitement for what’s ahead. It should be personal and authentic rather than generic. Several people mentioned that the most helpful advice they received was simply: “Give yourself permission to discover what retirement means for you rather than accepting someone else’s definition.”

What is the 60/30/10 rule for retirement?

The 60/30/10 rule for retirement is a budgeting framework that allocates retirement income across three categories: 60% for essential expenses (housing, healthcare, food, utilities, insurance), 30% for discretionary lifestyle spending (travel, hobbies, entertainment, dining out), and 10% for unexpected expenses and charitable giving. This framework provides structure while maintaining flexibility—during market downturns or unexpected expenses, you can reduce the discretionary 30% without compromising essential needs. Some financial planners also apply a 60/30/10 framework to retirement portfolio allocation: 60% growth investments, 30% income-producing assets, and 10% cash reserves. The specific percentages matter less than having a deliberate structure that separates needs from wants and ensures adequate buffers for uncertainty.

Your Path Forward: Turning Insights Into Action

What I learned from talking to 60 people about retiring early has fundamentally changed how I approach retirement planning conversations. Early retirement isn’t just about accumulating a certain net worth—it’s about building a comprehensive life plan that addresses financial security, healthcare coverage, tax optimization, social connection, and personal purpose.

The most important insight? You don’t need to be perfect, but you do need to be intentional. Start where you are. If you’re decades from retirement, focus on building that high savings rate and letting compound interest work its magic. If you’re closer, run detailed projections that account for healthcare costs, tax implications, and multiple scenarios. If you’re already retired or about to be, ensure you’ve addressed the emotional and social dimensions that often catch people unprepared.

Early retirement is achievable for many more people than realize it, but it requires moving beyond generic advice to personalized planning. Consider your unique circumstances, risk tolerance, values, and goals. What works for someone else may not work for you, and that’s completely fine.

The next step? Schedule time this week to evaluate where you stand. Calculate your current savings rate. Project your expenses in retirement. Identify your gaps—whether that’s healthcare planning, tax strategy, or purpose planning. Then address them one by one. You might also benefit from consulting with a qualified professional who can provide personalized guidance based on your specific situation.

Remember: the best time to start planning for early retirement was twenty years ago. The second best time is today.

This article provides educational information about retirement planning based on interviews and research. It is not personalized financial advice tailored to your specific situation. Individual circumstances vary significantly, and what worked for the people interviewed may not be appropriate for you. Consult a certified financial planner (CFP) or qualified financial advisor before making major retirement decisions.

Past investment performance doesn’t guarantee future results. All investments carry risk, including potential loss of principal. Market conditions, tax laws, and personal circumstances change over time. The strategies discussed require careful consideration of your unique financial situation, risk tolerance, and retirement timeline.